IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT KALABURAGI BENCH
ON Thursday THE 21st Day Of November 2024
at 10:30:00 AM
BEFORE
THE HON`BLE JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
COURT HALL NO : 5
LIST NO : Cause List No. 1

SlnoCase NoAdv for Pet/Appl/CompAdv for Resp

DICTATING JUDGMENT
1MFA 201857/2019
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(MV, D )ANURADHA M. DESAI &
RAVISHANT R MANI

BASAVARAJ R MATH & VIJAYALAXMI ADV`S FOR R1 & R2 R3 - RUDRAGOUDA SERVED R4 - KRISHNA REDDY SERVED R5 - HARISH PATTAR SERVED R6 - SUGURESHWAR SERVED SUDARSHAN M FOR R7
FURTHER HEARING
2MFA 201932/2018
A/W AFFIDAVIT DATED 17.09.2024 FILED BY ADV SUDARSHAN M WHO APPEARS FOR BAJAJ ALLIANZ GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY (V/O DATED 28.08.2024)
2) NON FILING OF ACK FOR HAVING
DEPOSITED 50% OF THE AWARD
AMOUNT (V/O DTD 14.12.2018)
(TCR K/B)
(DATE)
(MV, D )PREETI PATIL MELKUNDI

SHARANABASAPPA K BABSHETTY FOR R1 & R2 V/O DTD 13.07.2022 NOTICE TO R3- ANNARAYA GOUDA IS HELD SUFFICIENT
3MFA 200559/2022
A/W NON-FILING ACK FOR HAVING SERVED TWO SET COPIES OF APPEAL MEMO A/W ALL RELEVANT DOCUMENTS ON THE OTHER COUNSEL
(V/O DTD 13.11.2024)
(APPEAL ADMITTED)
(TCR RECEIVED)
(PART HEARD)
(DATE)
(MV, D )VISHAL PRATAP SINGH
& GIRISH KULKARNI

V/O DATED11.03.2022 NOTICE TO R1 & R2 IS DISPENSED WITH MANJUNATH MALLAYYA SHETTY FOR R3 (VK NOT FILED)
4MFA 202059/2022
(PART HEARD)
(DATE)
(MV, D )SANGANAGOUDA V BIRADAR

V/O DTD 20.10.2022 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH PREETI PATIL MELKUNDI FOR R2
FINAL HEARING
5MFA 201917/2018
(DATE)
(MV, D )SHARANAGOWDA V PATIL
V/O DTD 24.04.2019
NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH V/O DATED 25.05.2023 NOTICE TO R2 IS DISPENSED WITH S S ASPALLI FOR R3 (VK NOT FILED)
6MFA 202213/2018
(APPEAL ADMITTED)
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(MV, D )SANJEEV PATIL
KRUPA SAGAR PATIL FOR R1
(VK FILED) SUBHASH MALLAPUR FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
Connected With
MFA 201420/2018
-
(MV, D )SUBHASH MALLAPUR

SANJEEV PATIL FOR R1 TO R3 (VK NOT FILED) KRUPA SAGAR PATIL FOR R4 (VK FILED)
7MFA 201035/2021
(TCR RECEIVED)
(MV, D )PREETI PATIL MELKUNDI

B C JAKA FOR R1 & R2
8MFA 201212/2021
A/W NON-FILING OF VAKALATH BY ADVOCATE
SRI. S S ASPALLI APPEARING FOR R2
(V/O DTD 01.07.2024)
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(MV, D )SANGANABASAVA B PATIL

R1 - IRANNA SERVED V/O DTD 09.12.2021 S S ASPALLI FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
9MFA 200336/2023
(TCR RECEIVED)
(MV, D )BASAVARAJ R MATH
AND VIJAYLAXMI

V/O DATED 25.01.2023 NOTICE TO R1, R2, R4 AND R5 IS DISPENSED WITH SHIVANAND PATIL FOR R3 (VK NOT FILED)
10MFA 200511/2023
(APPEAL ADMITTED)
(TCR RECEIVED)
(MV, D )SANGANAGOUDA V BIRADAR

V/O DATED 08.02.2023 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH, SANGEETA BHADRASHETTY FOR R2 (VK FILED)
11MFA 200733/2023
(APPEAL ADMITTED)
(TCR RECEIVED)
(MV, D )SANJEEVKUMAR C PATIL

R1- PRAKASH - SD MANVENDRA REDDY FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
12MFA 202112/2023
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(MV, D )YASHAS S DIKSHIT
AND G V DESHPANDE

V/O DTD 12.07.2023 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH SUBHASH MALLAPUR FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
ADMISSION
13MFA 200150/2018
(DATE)
(MV, D )SANGANABASAVA B PATIL

R1- KASIM -SD R2- SHRISHAIL- SD PREETI PATIL MELKUNDI FOR R3
Connected With
MFA 202377/2017
REG: STEPS TO BE TAKEN IN R/O UNCLAIMED R4
(MV, I )PREETI PATIL MELKUNDI

SANGANABASAVA B PATIL FOR R1 & R2 (VK NOT FILED) R3 - KASIM- SERVED
14MFA 202492/2018
A/W IA 2/18 FOR PRODUCTION OF ADDL. DOCUMENTS
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(MV, D )BASAVARAJ R MATH

V/O DATED 12.09.2023 NOTICE TO R1 DISPENSED WITH S S ASPALLI FOR R2 & R4 (VK FILED) R3- SURYAKANTH SD
15MFA 200951/2019
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(MV, D )MANJUNATH MALLAYYA SHETTY
R2 IS MINOR REPRESENTED BY R1
NAGARAJ PATIL FOR R1 TO R4 (R2 IS MINOR U/G OF R1) S S SIDHAPURKAR & H M GILKI FOR R5
Connected With
MFA 200510/2020
-
(MV, D )NAGARAJ PATIL

V/O DTD 12.01.2021 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH S S ASPALLI FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
16MFA 200955/2019
(DATE)
(MV, D )RATNA N SHIVAYOGIMATH

V/O DATED 29.01.2024 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH S S ASPALLI FOR R2 (VK FILED)
Connected With
MFA 202132/2019
REG: IA 1/19 FOR CD OF 280 DAYS IN FILING THE ABOVE APPEAL
2) NON-FILING OF ACK FOR HAVING PAID COST OF RS. 200/- TO THE ADVOCATES ASSOCIATION LIBRARY FUND HIG COURT OF KARNATAKA KALABURAGI
(V/O DTD . 06.08.2023)
(DATE)
(MV, D ) S S ASPALLI

V/O DTD 14.11.2024 RATNA N SHIVAYOGIMATH FOR R1 TO R3 (VK NOT FILED) R4- DWARAKABAI SD R5- SATISH BHAIRU RAUT SD (R2 & R3 ARE MINORS U/G OF R1)
17MFA 201812/2019
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(MV, D )SANGANABASAVA B PATIL

S V DESHMUKH FOR R1 J AUGUSTIN FOR R2
18MFA 202501/2019
(TCR RECEIVED)
(MV, D )MANJUNATH MALLAYYA SHETTY

SHARANAGOUDA V PATIL FOR R1 & R2 R3- PRAKASH SD
Connected With
MFA 200329/2020
-
(MV, D )SHARANAGOWDA V PATIL

SANGANAGOUDA V BIRADAR FOR R1 (VK NOT FILED) C S KALBURGI FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED) MANJUNATH MALLAYYA SHETTY FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
MFA 202500/2019
(TCR RECEIVED)
(MV, D )MANJUNATH MALLAYYA SHETTY

SHARANAGOUDA V PATIL FOR R1 & R2 SANGANAGOUDA V BIRADAR FOR R3
MFA 200330/2020
-
(MV, D )SHARANAGOWDA V PATIL

SANGANAGOUDA V BIRADAR FOR R1 (VK NOT FILED) C S KALBURAGI FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED) MANJUNATH MALLAYYA SHETTY FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
19MFA 202549/2019
(DATE)
(MV, D )BABU H METAGUDDA

SANDEEP V PATIL FOR R1 SUDARSHAN M FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
20MFA 200501/2020
(DATE)
(MV, D )SANGANAGOUDA V BIRADAR

V/O DATED 12.01.2021 NOTICE TO R1 DISPENSED WITH, PREETI PATIL MELKUNDI FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
Connected With
MFA 200502/2020
-
(MV, D )SANGANAGOUDA V BIRADAR

V/O DATED 12.01.2021 NOTICE TO R1 DISPENSED WITH, PREETI PATIL MELKUNDIN FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
21MFA 200877/2020
-
(MV, D )PREETI PATIL MELKUNDI

BIRADAR VIRANAGOUDA FOR R1 TO R5 (VK FILED) (R3 TO R5 ARE MINORS U/G OF R2)
Connected With
MFA.CROB 200072/2021
REG: NON-FILING OF ACK FOR HAVING SERVED CROSS APPEAL COPY TO RESPONDENT
(MV, D )BIRADAR VIRANAGOUDA

SUDHIRSINGH R VIJAPUR (VK NOT FILED)
22MFA 200002/2021
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(MV, D )BASAVARAJ R MATH

V/O DATED 28.01.2021 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH C S KALBURGI FOR R2 (VK FILED)
23MFA 200121/2021
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(MV, D )BASAVARAJ R MATH
AND VIJAYLAXMI

V/O DATED 09.02.2021 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH V/O DATED 25.08.2022 NOTICE TO R2 IS DISPENSED WITH SUDARSHAN M FOR R3 (VK NOT FILED)
24MFA 200157/2021
(DD FILE- MFA 200398/2021,
MFA 200062/2021, MFA 200022/2021,
MFA 200062/2022, MFA 200065/2022 K/B)
(DATE)
(MV, D )SHANTANU
(VK FILED, NOC OBTAINED)

V/O DATED 30.03.2021 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH RAHUL R ASTURE FOR R2
Connected With
MFA 200653/2021
(TCR RECEIVED)
(MV, I )VEERANAGOUDA
MALIPATIL

V/O DTD 24.01.2022 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH RAHUL R ASTURE FOR R2 (VK FILED)
25MFA 201131/2021
-
(MV, D )BASAVARAJ R MATH

V/O DATED 24.6.2022 NOTICE TO R2 AND R3 IS DISPENSED WITH RAHUL R ASTURE FOR R1
26MFA 201197/2021
(DATE)
(MV, D )BASAVARAJ R MATH

V/O DATED 09.11.2021 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH SUDHIRSING R VIJAYAPUR FOR R2 (VK FILED)
27MFA 201274/2021
(DATE)
(MV, D )BABU H METAGUDDA

V/O DATED 13.01.2022 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH C S KALBURGI FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED) V/O DTD 02.02.2024 MANJUNATH MALLAYYA SHETTY FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
28MFA 200580/2023
-
(MV, D )VEERANAGOUDA
MALIPATIL

V/O DATED 07.12.2023 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH SUDARSHAN M FOR R2
29MFA 200804/2023
A/W NON-COMPLIANCE OF OFFICE OBJECTION
2) NON-FILING OF ACK FOR HAVING SERVED COPY OF APPEAL MEMO ON THE STANDING MEMO ON THE STANDING COUNSEL FOR R2 (V/O DTD 30.10.2024)
3) IA 1/22 FOR CD OF 19 DAYS IN FILING THE ABOVE APPEAL
(DATE)
(MV, D )PUNITH MARKAL

V/O DTD. 30.10.2024 S S ASPALLI FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
30MFA 201748/2024
(DATE)
(MV, D )SANJEEV PATIL

MOHD. ABDUL QUAYUM FO R2 (VK NOT FILED) V/O DTD 07.11.2024 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH
HEARING - INTERLOCUTORY APPLN
31MFA 200610/2019
REG: IA 1/2019 FOR CD OF 2487
DAYS IN FILING THE ABOVE APPEAL
(APPEAL ADMITTED)
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(MV, D )GANESH NAIK & A S RAWOOR

R1-MOHAN REDDY - SERVED C S KALBURGI FOR R2 (VK FILED) MANJUNATH MALLAYYA SHETTY FOR R2 (VK FILED)
32MFA 201669/2019
REG: IA 1/19 FOR CD OF 933 DAYS IN FILING THE ABOVE APPEAL
(DATE)
(MV, D )BABU H METAGUDDA

S S ASPALLI FOR R2 R1- ANJANNA - SERVED
33MFA 201467/2021
REG: IA 1/21 FOR CD OF 204 DAYS
IN FILING THE APPEAL
(DATE)
(MV, D )SANDEEP VIJAYKUMAR

SHARANABASAPPA M PATIL
Connected With
MFA 201252/2021
-
(MV, I )SANDEEP VIJAYKUMAR

MANJUNATH MALLAYYA SHETTY (VK NOT FILED) SHARANABASAPPA M PATIL (VK FILED)
MFA 201328/2021
-
(MV, I )SANDEEP VIJAYKUMAR

SHARANABASAPPA M PATIL (VK FILED)
MFA 201323/2021
-
(MV, I )SANDEEP VIJAYKUMAR

V/O DATED 04.01.2022 RATNA N SHIVAYOGIMATH (VK NOT FILED) SHARANABASAPPA M PATIL (VK FILED)
MFA 201329/2021
-
(MV, I )SANDEEP VIJAYKUMAR

MANJUNATH MALLYYA SHETTY (VK NOT FILED) SHARANABASAPPA M PATIL (VK FILED)
34MFA 200461/2023
REG: IA 1/23 FOR CD OF 33 DAYS IN FILING THE ABOVE APPEAL
(MV, D )PREETI PATIL MELKUNDI

KRUPA SAGAR PATIL FOR R1 TO R9 R10- MAINUDDIN- SERVED
ORDERS
35MFA 203109/2024
REG: AWAITING SERVICE IN R/O R1
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(MV, D )BAPUGOUDA SIDDAPPA

V/O DTD 07.11.2024 SANJAY M JOSHI FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT KALABURAGI BENCH
ON Thursday THE 21st Day Of November 2024
at 14:30:00 PM
BEFORE
THE HON`BLE JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
COURT HALL NO : 5
LIST NO : Cause List No. 2

SlnoCase NoAdv for Pet/Appl/CompAdv for Resp

PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDER
1WP 200803/2019
(S)
(S, RES )D P AMBEKAR & SANJAY M JOSHI
GOVT. ADVOCATE
FOR R1 TO R3, R5 & R7 (MA NOT FILED) PRASHANT S KUMMAN FOR R4 & R6 (VK NOT FILED)
2WP 226185/2020
-
(S, REG )NITESH VILAS KUMAR
AND S B WADI

SHOWRI H R, KAVYASHREE, VISHWARADHYA K IJERI & RAKSHITH JOIS FOR R1 GIRISH P S FOR R2
PRELIMINARY HEARING
3WP 203215/2024
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(S, RES )BABU H METAGUDDA

GA - SERVED
4WP 203216/2024
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(S, RES )BABU H METAGUDDA

GA - SERVED
5WP 203217/2024
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(S, RES )BABU H METAGUDDA

GA - SERVED
FURTHER HEARING
6MFA 201614/2018
(V/O DTD 24.10.2024, HEARD IN PART)
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(WC, )BABU H METAGUDDA

V/O DATED 22.07.2021 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH SANJAY M JOSHI FOR R2 (VK FILED)
7MFA 202165/2018
(V/O DTD 25.10.2024 HEARD IN PART)
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(WC, )ANURADHA M. DESAI

R1 - ORANGE TOURS & TRAVELS SISTER CONCERN OF THIRUMALA CABS HYDERABAD, TELANGANA STATE REPRESENTED BY ITS ASST. GENERAL MANAGER (ADMIN) - SERVED SANTOSH BIRADAR FOR R2 (R3 TO R6 ARE MINORS U/G OF R2) R7 - SAREPPA - SERVED
8WP 200247/2021
(PART HEARD)
(DATE)
(S, RES )G G CHAGASHETTI
I R BIRADAR AND S S DESAI

ADDL. GOVT ADVOCATE FOR R1 TO R4 D P AMBEKAR FOR R5
FINAL HEARING
9MFA 200895/2019
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(MV, I )JIDAGE KAILASH. C

R1-MAIBUB - SD SUDARSHAN M FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
ADMISSION
10MFA 200832/2015
(DATE)
(CPC, )RAVI B PATIL

R3 - RAGHAVENDRA -SERVED R4 - SHRIDEVI - SERVED R5 - USHA LATA - SERVED R1- SHANTABAI W/O GURURAJ MUJUMADHAR R2- NAGARAJ S/O GURURAJ MUJUMADHAR R6- REKHA A KULKARNI
11MFA 202052/2019
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(LAC, )GA

SACHIN M MAHAJAN (VK FILED)
12MFA 200813/2020
(DATE)
(ECA , )S S MAMADAPUR

V/O DATED 28.01.2021 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH SUDARSHAN M FOR R2
13MFA 201662/2021
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(MV, I )KOUJALAGI CHANDRAKANT LAXMAN

PREETI PATIL MELKUNDI FOR R2 R1- DADAN - SERVED
14MFA 202684/2023
(APPEAL ADMITTED)
(TCR RECEIVED)
(DATE)
(ISA, )SUDARSHAN M
S S NAGARALE & PRASANNA KUMAR

15MFA 203485/2023
A/W IA 1/23 FOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTION
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(CPC, )SYED FAYAZUDDIN
AND ASLAM SAYEED

R1- MOHAMMED AMOULANA SAB - SD R2- HAJI MOHAMMED ABDUL HAMEED - SD R3- MOHAMMED NOORUDDIN - SD R4- MOHAMMED YUSUF - SD R5- MOHAMMED AKBAR - SD R6- MOHAMMED AMJAD - SD
16MFA 203695/2023
(APPEAL ADMITTED)
(DATE)
(CPC, )HEMA L KULAKARNI
LAXMIKANT H K & MANJUNATH GINNI

SANGANABASAVA B PATIL FOR C/R (IN CP NO. 31691/2023)
Connected With
MFA 203726/2023
(APPEAL ADMITTED)
(CPC, )SANGANABASAVA B PATIL

V/O DTD 29.10.2024 HEMA L K FOR RESPONDENT (VK NOT FILED)
17MFA 204154/2023
A/W IA 2/24 FOR STAY
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(ECA , )SUDARSHAN M

NARENDRA REDDY FOR R1 AND R2 (VK FILED NOTICE NOT ORDERED)
18MFA 200730/2024
A/W IA 1/24 FOR STAY
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(MV, I )SUDARSHAN M

19MFA 201082/2024
A/W IA 2/24 FOR STAY
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(MV, )SUDARSHAN M

20MFA 201321/2024
A/W IA 1/24 FOR STAY
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(MV, I )SUDARSHAN M

SANGANAGOUDA V BIRADAR FOR C/R-1 IN CP NO. 30721/2024
21MFA 202345/2024
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(MV, I )SANJEEV PATIL

22MFA 202927/2024
A/W IA 1/24 FOR STAY
(DATE)
(MV, I )PREETI PATIL MELKUNDI

SANJEEV PATIL FOR C/R-1 IN CP No.30841/2024
HEARING - INTERLOCUTORY APPLN
23MFA 201315/2024
(S)
REG: IA 1/24 FOR CD OF 153 DAYS IN FILING THE ABOVE APPEAL
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(MV, I )BAPUGOUDA SIDDAPPA

24MFA 203415/2024
REG: IA 1/24 FOR CD OF 30 DAYS IN FILING THE ABOVE APPEAL
2) IA 2/24 FOR STAY
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(MV, I )MOHD ABDUL QUAYUM

25WP 203218/2024
REG: IA 1/24 FOR DISPENSATION WITH PRODUCTION OF CERTIFIED COPY OF ANNEXURE-E
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(S, RES )BABU H METAGUDDA

GA - SERVED
ORDERS
26MFA 200872/2020
REG: NON-RECEIPT OF TCR
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(MV, I )BASAVARAJ R MATH

V/O DTD 01.06.2021 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH S M PATIL FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED)
Connected With
MFA 200871/2020
REG: NON-RECEIPT OF TCR
(MV, I )BASAVARAJ R MATH

V/O DTD 12.11.2021 NOTICE TO R1 IS DISPENSED WITH MANVENDRA REDDY FOR R2
27MFA 202805/2024
REG: COUNSEL SUBMISSION WITH REGARD TO MAINTAINABILITY OF THE APPEAL
(DATE)
(MV, I )MOHD ABDUL QUAYUM

28MFA 202810/2024
REG: COUNSEL SUBMISSION WITH REGARD TO MAINTAINABILITY OF APPEAL
(DATE)
(MV, I )MOHD ABDUL QUAYUM

29MFA 203216/2024
REG: NON-FURNISHING OF ACK FOR HAVING DEPOSITED INTEREST AMOUNT OF AWARD BEFORE TRIBUNAL
(DATE)
(ECA , )RATNA N SHIVAYOGIMATH
& S S HIREMATH

30WP 200127/2024
REG: FURNISHING OF PF, COVER, ACK CORRECT ADDRESS FOR ISSUING NOTICE TO R1, R2, R5, R6 & R7
(FOR 1ST TIME)
(MEMO FOR POSTING)
(S, RES )MANURE ASHOK KUMAR

GOURISH S KHASHAMPUR FOR R3 & R4