| IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD BENCH ON Friday THE 27th Day Of September 2024 at 10:30:00 AM BEFORE | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| THE HON`BLE JUSTICE HANCHATE SANJEEVKUMAR | |||||||||
| COURT HALL NO : 8 LIST NO : Cause List No. 1 | |||||||||
| Slno | Case No | Adv for Pet/Appl/Comp | Adv for Resp | ||||||
| ORDERS | |||||||||
| 1 | RSA 895/2004 REG: THIS APPEAL IS REMITTED BACK TO COURT BY HON`BLE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA AS PER ORDER IN CIVIL APPEAL No.10743/2014 (PB KEPT BELOW) | (INJ, ) | ANAND ASHTEKAR SHEKHARGOUDA M NAGANURI (VK RETURNED WITH O/O) SRINAND A PACHCHAPURE | MRUTYUNJAY TATA BANGI G S KANNUR | |||||
| 2 | RSA 5558/2013 (APPEAL ADMITTED 17-4-2023) REG: 1) NON FILING OF PAPER BOOKS 2) IA-1/2024 FOR EXTENSION OF STAY (MOVED) | (SP, ) | VIJAYENDRA BHIMAKKANAVAR | MAHESH WODEYAR FOR R1 PRUTHVI K S FOR R2 | |||||
| 3 | RSA 100506/2016 REG: 1) FURNISHING OF PF, COVER, COPY, ACK & CORRECT ADDRESS TO ISSUE E/NOTICE TO R5, R10 & R11 2) IA-1/2024 FOR CD OF 785 DAYS IN FILING LR`S APPLICATION 3) IA-2/2024 FOR SETTING ASIDE THE ABATEMENT OF R8 4) IA-3/2024 FOR BRINGING LR`S OF DECEASED R8 ON RECORD AS PROP. R8(A-D) 4) IA-1/2016 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (PAR, ) | VIJAYKUMAR B HORATTI (NOC) AHAMED ALI J RAHIMAN SHAH | R1-R3 : M H PATIL & HARSHAWARDHANA M PATIL R4-APPANNA: SD R6, R7, R9 : SERVICE HELD SUFFICIENT R5, R10, R11 : LEFT | |||||
| 4 | RSA 100522/2021 REG: OFFICE OBJECTION AT SL.NO. 6 A/W COUNSEL SUBMISSION 2) COMPLIANCE OF OFFICE OBJECTION AT SL.NO. 3A, 7 (MOVED) | (DEC/POS, ) | G R TURAMARI V S KOUJALAGI | ||||||
| 5 | RSA 100589/2023 REG: COMPLIANCE OF OFFICE OBJECTION RAISED ON IA-1/2024 & IA-2/2024 FOR RECALLING FILED BY SRI. MRUTYUNJAY R YARAGAMBLIMATH (CH MOVED) | (INJ, ) | M.M.KORIMATH | ||||||
| 6 | RSA 100171/2024 REG: 1) AWAITING SERVICE OF NOTICE TO SOLE RESPONDENT (POSTAL TRACK REPORT K/B) 2) NON FILING OF MEMO OF ACK FOR HAVING SERVED HAND SUMMONS 3) IA-1/2024 FOR STAY (DATE) | (, ) | DINESH M KULKARNI | ||||||
| 7 | RSA 100569/2024 REG: 1) NON COMPLIANCE OF OFFICE OBJECTION AT SL.NO. 3, 5 2) COMPLIANCE OF OFFICE OBJECTION AT SL.NO. 12 (MOVED) | (PAR/POS, ) | NAGANGOUDA R KUPPELUR | ||||||
| HEARING - INTERLOCUTORY APPLN | |||||||||
| 8 | RSA 100050/2014 REG: IA-1/2024 FOR CD OF 2819 DAYS IN FILING RECALLING APPLICATION & RECALLING ORDER DATED 18-12-2014 (CH MOVED) | (, ) | VITTHAL S TELI | ||||||
| 9 | RSA 100131/2017 (APPEAL ADMITTED 15-9-2022) REG: 1) IA-1/2024 FOR T.I. 2) MEMO FOR PRODUCING DOCUMENTS FILED BY ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT (PB K/B) (CH MOVED) | (SP, ) | SHRIHARSH A NEELOPANT (NOC) | BHARATI G BHAT | |||||
| 10 | RSA 100677/2019 REG: IA 1/2019 FOR CD OF 118 DAYS IN FILING (MOVED) | (SP, ) | PRAKASH N HOSAMANE | R2 : VISHWANATH HEGDE & TANUJA HEGDE R1 : YAMANAVVA - SD | |||||
| 11 | RSA 100466/2021 REG: 1) IA-1/2024 FOR CD OF 272 DAYS IN FILING RECALLING APPLICATION 2) IA-2/2024 FOR RECALLING ORDER DATED 29-11-2023 (CH MOVED) | (DEC/INJ, ) | SHARMILA M PATIL | ||||||
| 12 | RSA 100040/2022 REG: IA-1/2024 FOR CORRECTION OF IA-1/2022 V/O/DTD 23-7-2024 (MOVED) | (DEC/INJ, ) | G B NAIK and SMT P G NAIK | ||||||
| 13 | RSA 101557/2022 REG: 1) IA-4/2024 FOR DISPENSATION 2) IA-3/2024 FOR CD OF 176 DAYS IN FILING 3) IA-1/2022 FOR T.I. (MOVED) | (PAR/POS, ) | MANJUNATH A KARIGANNAVAR | ||||||
| 14 | RSA 100174/2023 REG: IA-1/2024 FOR CD OF 43 DAYS IN FILING RECALLING APPLICATION & RECALLING ORDER DATED 8-7-2024 (MOVED) | (DEC/INJ, ) | SADIQ N GOODWALA | ||||||
| 15 | RSA 100232/2023 REG: 1) IA-1/2024 FOR CD OF 272 DAYS IN FILING RECALLING APPLICATION 2) IA-2/2024 FOR RECALLING ORDER DATED 23-4-2024 (CH MOVED) | (PAR/POS, ) | D L LADKHAN M L LADKHAN | ||||||
| 16 | RSA 100375/2023 REG: IA-1/2024 FOR CD OF 164 DAYS IN FILING (MOVED) | (PAR/POS, ) | S M KALWAD JAYAWANT KAMBLI ASHOK ANGADI | ||||||
| 17 | RSA 100421/2023 REG: IA-1/2024 FOR CD OF 150 DAYS IN FILING RECALLING APPLICATION & RECALLING ORDER DATED 20-3-2024 (MOVED) | (PAR/POS, ) | SANGRAM S KULKARNI | ||||||
| 18 | RSA 100627/2023 REG: 1) IA-1/2024 FOR CD OF 162 DAYS IN FILING RECALLING APPLICATION 2) IA-2/2024 FOR RECALLING ORDER DATED 15-3-2024 (MOVED) | (DEC/POS, ) | A P HEGDE JANMANE VIJAY MALALI | ||||||
| 19 | RSA 100741/2023 REG IA-1/2024 FOR CD OF 163 DAYS IN FILING RECALLING APPLICATION & RECALLING THE ORDER DATED 15-3-2024 (MOVED) | (DEC/INJ, ) | ANAND D BAGEWADI | RAMAKRISHNA HEGDE FOR C/R1 IN CP 21174/2023 | |||||
| 20 | RSA 100286/2024 REG: 1) IA-1/2024 FOR CD OF 654 DAYS IN FILING 2) IA-2/2024 FOR STAY 3) MEMO OF ACK FOR HAVING SERVED APPEAL MEMO (DATE), | (DEC, ) | HANUMANTHAREDDY SAHUKAR | R1-R8 : S R HEGDE & B N KUNTOJI R9 : BASAVARAJ - SD | |||||
| 21 | RSA 100584/2024 REG: 1) IA-1/2024 FOR CD OF 90 DAYS IN FILING 2) IA-2/2024 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (DEC/POS, ) | MAHESH N. KULKARNI TEJPAL A KAMAL VANDANA P MURKATE | ||||||
| ADMISSION | |||||||||
| 22 | RSA 100063/2017 (CH MOVED) | (POS, ) | SHUBHENDU A AKALWADI P VADIRAJ | ||||||
| 23 | RSA 100222/2019 A/W IA 1/2019 FOR STAY (DATE) | (PAR, ) | RAVI S BALIKAI FOR A1(A TO I) | K RAGHAVENDRA RAO and V VIDYA IYER FOR C/R1 & C/R2 CP 20146/2019 VISHWANATH HEGDE FOR R3 R4, R5 : NOTICE DISPENSED WITH | |||||
| 24 | RSA 100509/2021 A/W IA 1/2021 FOR STAY (MOVED) | (PAR/POS, ) | S G KADADAKATTI | DINESH M KULKARNI | |||||
| 25 | RSA 100266/2023 A/W IA 1/2023 FOR STAY A/W STATEMENT OF OBJECTIONS (BOTH TCR`S RA & OS K/B) (DATE) | (PAR/POS, ) | C.S SHETTAR KAVYA C SHETTAR | GIRISH S HIREMATH & C S RACHAYYANAVAR | |||||
| 26 | RSA 100306/2023 A/W IA-1/2023 FOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTION (DATE), | (SP, ) | MALLIKARJUNSWAMY B HIREMATH UMESH P HAKKARAKI | GANAPATI M BHAT FOR R1 AND R2 | |||||
| 27 | RSA 100061/2024 A/W IA 2/2024 FOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTION (BOTH TCR`S K/B) (MOVED) | (SP, ) | MRUTYUNJAY TATA BANGI S S YALIGAR | S L MATTI & RAVINDRA S KARADI | |||||
| 28 | RSA 100445/2024 A/W IA-1/2024 FOR STAY (MOVED) | (PAR/POS, ) | S B HEBBALLI V B DAMMURMATH | ||||||
| 29 | RSA 100499/2024 A/W IA-1/2024 FOR STAY (MOVED) | (SP, ) | SHIVANAND MALASHETTI | ||||||
| 30 | RSA 100625/2024 A/W IA 2/2024 FOR STAY (DATE) | (SP, ) | SHARAD MALGOUND PATIL | GANAPATI M BHAT FOR C/R2 IN CP NO.22862/2024 PRUTHVI K S FOR R1 | |||||
| Connected With | |||||||||
| RSA 100624/2024 REG : 1) IA 2/2024 FOR STAY A/W STATEMENT OF OBJECTION FILED BY R2 2) IA 3/2024 FOR DISPENSATION | (SP, ) | PRUTHVI K S | GANAPATI M BHAT C/R2 IN CP NO.22861/2024 (RETURNED WITH O/O) SHARAD M PATIL FOR R1 | ||||||
| 31 | RSA 100665/2024 A/W IA-1/2024 FOR STAY (MOVED) | (INJ, ) | TEJPAL KAMAL | ||||||
| 32 | RSA 100691/2024 A/W IA-1/2024 FOR STAY (DATE), | (INJ, ) | H N GULARADDI YALAGI KAVYA SHIVAPPA | ||||||
| 33 | RSA 100698/2024 A/W IA-1/2024 FOR STAY (MOVED) | (FDP, ) | S B HEBBALLI | ||||||
| FOR FURTHER DICTATION | |||||||||
| 34 | RSA 100659/2024 A/W IA-1/2024 FOR STAY (TCR`S RA+OS+FDP ARE K/B) (DATE), | (FDP, ) | A S PATIL SABEEL AHAMED S K HOSAMANI | C/R GOPINATH KIDIYOOR (PARTY IN PERSON) (CP 22226/2024 RETURNED WITH OFFICE OBJECTION) | |||||
| FURTHER ARGUMENTS | |||||||||
| 35 | RSA 5282/2012 (APPEAL ADMITTED 8/3/2021) (PART HEARD) A/W 1) IA 1/2021 FOR STAY 2) IA 2/2021 FOR EARLY HEARING 3) IA-1/2024 FOR PRODUCTION OF ADDL. DOCUMENTS (V/O/DTD 17-9-2024 OBJECTION TO IA-1/2024 HAS NOT FILED) (PB IS DISPENSED WITH) (BOTH TCR`S K/B) (DATE), | (DEC/INJ, ) | T BASAVANA GOUD | HANUMANTHAREDDY SAHUKAR FOR R1(A-E) | |||||
| 36 | RSA 100883/2018 (APPEAL ADMITTED ON 16.09.2022) REG: 1) NON-TAKING STEPS IN R/O DECEASED R6 AS PER ORDER DTD: 19.03.2024 2) IA 1/2022 FOR DIRECTION (PAPER BOOK DISPENSED WITH) (DATE) | (SP, ) | K RAGHAVENDRA RAO : V VIDYA IYER | GANAPATI M BHAT FOR R1 TO R5 T M NADAF AND GAYATRI S R FOR R9 AND R10 VEERESH BUDIHAL FOR R11 R7-LAKSHMI: SD R8-CHANDRAMMA: SD | |||||
| FURTHER HEARING | |||||||||
| 37 | RSA 101016/2016 (APPEAL ADMITTED 27/09/2022) A/W IA 2/2022 FOR AMENDMENT OF PETITION (PAPER BOOK K/B 1 NO.) (STATEMENT OF OBJECTION TO IA NO.2/2022 FILED BY ADV. FOR RESPONDENT) (DATE) | (DEC, ) | H M DHARIGOND (NOC OBTAINED) | ANAND BAGEWADI FOR R1(B), R1(C) & R1(E) GANESH RAIBAGI FOR R1 (D) R1(B), R1(C), R1(D) & R1(E) ARE TREATED AS LR`S OF DECEASED R1(A) R2-VIJAY S/O GAJANAN OULKAR-HELD SUFFICIENT R M HIREMATH, SUJEET S HIREMATH & ARADHANA MANVI FOR R3 (NOC OBTAINED) | |||||
| FINAL HEARING | |||||||||
| 38 | RSA 2527/2005 (APPEAL ADMITTED 6-6-2008) (PAPER BOOK K/B) | (DEC/INJ, ) | LAXMAN T MANTAGANI and N M HANDRAL | P G MOGALI H M DHARIGOND | |||||
| 39 | RSA 294/2006 (APPEAL ADMITTED 19.09.2008) A/W IA-1/2024 FOR STAY (FDP No.13/2021) (PAPER BOOK K/B) (DATE), | (PAR, ) | MRUTYUNJAY TATA BANGI SHASHIKALA M BANGI | RAVI G SABHAHITH FOR R1(A-D) and R8 TO R10, R16, R18, R19 & R27 DINESH M KULKARNI FOR R1(B) (NOC) R4 : VITTHAL S TELI V/O/DTD: 25-2-2010 R2 & R15 ARE DELETED V/O/DTD: 25-2-2010 R26,R28,R29,R32,R33 : ARE EXEMPTED V/O/DTD: 15-9-2010 R7 & R14 : ARE ABATED V/O/DTD: 29-5-2013 R22 & R23 : ARE ABATED V/O/DTD. 30.03.2022 A1(i TO iv) & R39 ARE LR`S OF DECEASED APPELLANT R3 : KALLAPPA - SD R5 : SHANKAR - SD R6 : BASAVANTH -SD R11 : MUKTABAI - SD R12, R43 : DECEASED R20 : SUBHADRA - SD R24 : NARAYAN - SD R25 : MURALIDHAR - SD R35 : SHAKUNTALABAI - SD R36 : SATYABHAMA - SD R38 : ATMARAM - SD R39 : RAVATIBAI - SD R40 : DEVAKIBAI - SD R41 : ULLAS - SD R42 : KISHAN - SD R44 : SHANKUNTALABAI - SD, R17 : IS MINOR REP BY M/G R16, V/O/D: 8-12-09 R30 : BALAWANT - HELD SUFFICIENT R31 : PANDIT - HELD SUFFICIENT R34 : KAMALABAI - HELD SUFFICIENT R37 : JYOTIBA - HELD SUFFICIENT V/O DTD 31/7/2023, APPEAL IS ABATED AS AGAINST R3, R8, R24, R25 & R27 V/O DTD 29/8/2023, APPEAL AGAINST R13 AND R21 IS DISMISSED AS ABATED V/O/DTD 31-7-2024 R12, R43 : APPEAL ABATED | |||||
| 40 | RSA 1831/2006 (APPEAL ADMITTED 05/10/2012) A/W IA-3/2024 FOR FRAMING SUBSTANTIAL QUESTION OF LAW SYNOPSIS FILED BY BOTH COUNSELS) (PAPER BOOK K/B) (DATE), | (DEC, ) | P H GOTKHINDI C N HARLAPUR & S S TATTIMANI FOR A1(A, C TO I) ARE GPA HOLDERS TO A1(B) C N HARLAPUR FOR PROP. A1(i) | VISHWANATH S BICHAGATTI, P C SAJJANAL S S HULAGERI FOR R1 (NOC OBTAINED) R2-SHANTABAI - SD R3-SARASWATIBAI - SD R4-GEETABAI - SD R5-RAVI - SD R6-BABU - SD R7-DATTATREYA -HELD SUFFICIENT R8-DECEASED R8(A) : RAMESH : SERVED R8(B) : YALLAMMA : SERVED R8(C TO F) ARE MINORS R/BY R8(B) R8(G) : SHEKAPPA : SERVED R8(H): AKKAMMA : SERVED R9 -YALLAPPA NARAPPA- SD R10-DECEASED R10(A) : TARAVVA : SERVED R10(B) : MANJULA : SERVED R10(C) : BHARATI : SERVED R10(D) : NARAPPA : SERVED V/O/DTD: 17.11.2011 R2 TO R10 IS DISPENSED WITH | |||||
| 41 | RSA 2843/2006 (APPEAL ADMITTED 13.12.2007) A/W 1) MEMO DATED : 19/7/2024 FILED BY ADV FOR APPELLANT 2) MEMO DATED : 6/8/2024 FILED BY ADV FOR R1 4) MEMO OF CITATION DATED 23-9-2024 FILED BY ADV FOR APPELLANT 4) MEMO A/W ACK FOR HAVING PAID COST OF Rs.5,000/- TOWARDS ADV. ASSOCIATION LIBRARY FUND, HCK, DHARWAD 5) OFFICE OBJECTION RAISED ON MEMO DTD.03/05/2014 (DISPENSATION OF PAPER BOOK BUT ALREADY FILED PAPER BOOK HENCE CLARIFIED) (PAPER BOOK K/B) (DATE), | (SP, ) | V R DATAR RAMESH N MISALE FOR A2(A) TO 2(E) | C R GOULAY and VIDYANAND V ARALI FOR C/R1 (CP NO.86/07) R2- SHARADA -SD | |||||
| 42 | RSA 2892/2006 (APPEAL ADMITTED 23.03.2007) A/W 1) MEMO DTD. 20.01.2024 IN R/O GPA 2) MEMO FOR PRODUCTION OF COPY OF GPA/SPA FILED BY ADV. FOR APPELLANT 3) IA 1/2022 FOR CLUBBING THE WP MATTERS WITH THIS APPEAL (WP MATTERS ARE PENDING BEFORE PRL. BENCH BENGALURU) (PAPER BOOK K/B) (DATE), | (INJ, ) | PHANIRAJ KASHYAP AND GANAPATI M BHAT ADVS FOR VAKALATH FOR APPELLANT THROUGH GPA HOLDER GPA HOLDER OF SRI. R K VADIRAJ (PHOTOCOPY OF GPA COPY FILED) | SATISH S RAICHUR THROUGH GPA HOLDER SRI. V R GUTTAL (NOC) KOLAR & KOLAR ADVS. BY ANIL KEMBHAVI, LINGAMURTHY & VEENA HEGDE FOR C/R CP 858/2006 | |||||
| 43 | RSA 63/2007 (APPEAL ADMITTED 29.03.2011) (PAPER BOOK K/B) (DATE), | (INJ, ) | SANGRAM S KULKARNI | GANAPATI M BHAT FOR R1 (A TO C) | |||||
| 44 | RSA 5286/2013 (APPEAL ADMITTED 11-9-2024) 1) FILING OF PAPER BOOKS 2)IA 1/2017 FOR VACATING THE STAY ORDER DTD 04/04/2016 (AWAITING TCR IN OS) (DATE) | (DEC/INJ, ) | SANTOSH NARGUND (NOC OBTAINED) PRAKASH S UDIKERI | PRAKASH ANDANIMATH FOR R2, R3, R11 & R13 B V SOMAPUR FOR R1(A-F) & R1(G)(A) (VK NOT FILED IN R/O R1(G)(A)) R1(G): "DECEASED" R1(G)(B) : KAMALAXI : SD R1(G)(C) : SHAILAWWA : HELD SUFFICIENT R1(G)(D) : SAVITRI : SD R1(G)(E) : KALKAVVA : SD K L PATIL : S S BETURMATH, B G INDI & S B NAIK FOR R14 R4 : ADIVEPPA - SD R5 : NAGANAGOUDA - SD R6 : SHEKARAGOUDA - SD R7 : KAMALAVVA - SD R8 : SHANKARAGOUDA - SD R9 : MALLANAGOUDA - SD R10 : SHIDDAVVA - SD R12 : IRANAGOUDA - SD | |||||
| 45 | RSA 101138/2022 (APPEAL ADMITTED 28.09.2022) REG: 1) NON FILING OF PAPER BOOKS AS PER ORDER DTD: 11.09.2024 2) IA-1/2024 FOR EARLY HEARING FILED BY ADV. FOR RESPONDENT 3) IA-2/2024 FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS 4) IA-3/2024 EVIDENCE (DATE), | (PAR/POS, ) | B V SOMAPUR C B SHAKUNAVALLI | GIRISH A YADWAD FOR C/R1 & R2 IN CP NO 22368/2022, 22369/2022 | |||||