| IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD BENCH ON Friday THE 27th Day Of September 2024 at 10:30:00 AM BEFORE | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| THE HON`BLE JUSTICE B.M.SHYAM PRASAD & THE HON`BLE JUSTICE C M JOSHI | |||||||||
| COURT HALL NO : 3 LIST NO : Cause List No. 1 | |||||||||
| Slno | Case No | Adv for Pet/Appl/Comp | Adv for Resp | ||||||
| ORDERS | |||||||||
| 1 | RFA 100270/2020 REG: 1) COURT NOTICE ISSUED TO SOLE APPELLANT SERVICE REPORT STATING THAT APPELLANT DIED 2) NON FILING OF PAPER BOOK 3) NON FILING OF ACK FOR HAVING PAID THE COST OF Rs.1000/- TO THE REGISTRY VIDE COURT ORDER DATED : 27/11/2023 (ADMITTED 12-02-2023) (TCR RECD AT TCR BRANCH) | (PAR/POS, ) | SHIVAJI (APPELLANT) COURT NOTICE ISSUED TO SOLE APPELLANT & SERVICE REPORT RECEIVED STATING THAT SOLE APPELLANT DIED | SACHIDANANDA B P FOR R7 & R8 R1 : C S SHETTAR & KAVYA C SHETTAR R2 : ANAND -SD R3 : MUDEWWA -SD R4 : YAMANAWWA -SD R5 : RUKMAWWA -SD V/O DTD. 28/06/2021 APPELLANT IS TREATED AS LR`S OF DECEASED R6 | |||||
| 2 | RFA 100562/2023 REG: 1) AWAITING OF SERVICE OF E/NOTICE TO PROPOSED R1(A TO D) 2) IA 2/2023 FOR STAY (IA 1/2024 FOR BRINGING LRS OF DECEASED R1 ON RECORD AS PROPOSED R1(A TO D) & IA-1/2023 FOR CD OF 276 DAYS IN FILING THE APPEAL ARE PENDING) (CH MOVED) | (DEC/POS, ) | GIRISH A YADAWAD RAHUL S KUNTOJI DIVYA J DESHPANDE | R1-DECEASED R2-MAHALAXMI-SD R3-NETRAVATI-SD R4-VEDAVATI-SD R5-PARVATI-SD R6-MAHABALESHWAR-SD R7-SEETARAM-SD R8-MANJUNATH-SD R9-DATTATRAY-SD R10-VEENA-SD R11-PALLAVI-SD R12-PRATHVI-SD | |||||
| HEARING - INTERLOCUTORY APPLN | |||||||||
| 3 | RFA 100017/2017 REG: 1) IA 3/2024 FOR STAY 2) IA 4/2024 FOR PRODUCTION OF ADDL. DOCUMENTS (ADMITTED ON 10/03/2017) (TCR RECEIVED AT TCR BRANCH) (PB K/B) (CH MOVED) | (PAR, ) | B SHARANABASAWA FOR A3(A TO E) (VK) | DINESH M KULKARNI FOR R1 & R2 V/O/DTD. 28.11.2023 APPEAL AGAINST R3 IS DISMISSED RAJASHEKHAR R GUNJALLI FOR R4 R5 : THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER N.E.K.S.R.T.C DIVISIONAL OFFICER, KOPPAL -SD S K KAYAKAMATH FOR R6 TO R10 | |||||
| Connected With | |||||||||
| RFA.CROB 100007/2017 IN RFA 100017/2017 REG: 1) IA-1/2017 FOR CD OF 112 DAYS IN FILING THE CROSS APPEAL 2) IA 1/2023 FOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTION (NOTICE NOT ORDERED TO OTHER RESPONDENTS IN THIS CROSS OBJECTION) | (POS, ) | DINESH M KULKARNI | S K KAYAKAMATH FOR R1(A TO F) B SHARANABASAWA FOR R6(A TO D) | ||||||
| 4 | RFA 100458/2019 REG: IA-1/2023 FOR EARLY HEARING (ADMITTED ON 12.11.2019) (TCR RECEIVED AT TCR BRANCH) (PB K/B) | (DEC/PAR, ) | G B NAIK and SMT P G NAIK | DINESH M KULKARNI FOR C/R1 IN CP NO. 20238/2019 DINESH M KULKARNI FOR R1, R4 & R5 V/O/DTD. 27.01.2022 R2-DELETED V M SHEELVANT, VINAY S KOUJALAGI M L VANTI & ROHIT L SHEELVANT FOR R3(a) & (e) R3(B & C) : SERVED R3(D) IS MINOR R/BY R3(B) | |||||
| Connected With | |||||||||
| RFA 100489/2019 REG: 1) NON COMPLIANCE OF O/O RAISED ON AMENDED CAUSE TITLE i.e. PROPER AMENDED CAUSE TITLE TO BE FILED IN R/O DECEASED APPELLANT ON RECORD AS APPELLANT NO 1(a) AND (b) 2) IA-2/2022 FOR BRINGING LRS OF DECD APPELLANT ON RECORD AS PROP R7 TO R9 3) MEMO DATED: 18-03-2021 FOR REPORTING DEATH OF R2 FILED BY ADVOCATE SRI. DINESH M KULKARNI 4) IA-1/2019 FOR STAY (NOTICE NOT ORDERED TO OTHER RESPONDENTS i.e, R5 & R6 IN THIS APPEAL) | (DEC/PAR, ) | V M SHEELVANT S H MITTALKOD VINAY S KOUJALAGI M L VANTI FOR A1(A & B) | DINESH M KULKARNI FOR R1, R3 & R4 (VK FILED BEFORE ISSUANCE OF NOTICE) PROP R7-SERVED (R8 & R9 MINORS REP BY THEIR NATURAL GUARDIAN MOTHER PROP R7) | ||||||
| RFA 100068/2022 REG: 1) FURNISHING OF PF, COVER, CORRECT ADDRESS COPIES ETC FOR ISSUE NOTICE TO PROPOSED R1(A) (FOR II TIME) 2) STEPS TO BE TAKEN IN R/O UNSERVED R4 FOR SERVICE OF NOTICE (III TIME NOTICE ISSUED) (IA 1/2024 FOR CD OF 640 DAYS IN FILING THE APPLICATION 2) IA 2/2024 FOR SETTING ASIDE ABATEMENT 3) IA 3/2024 FOR BRINGING THE LRS OF DECEASED R1 ON RECORD AS R1(a) AND TREATING THE A1 TO A3 AND R4 ARE LRS OF DECEASED R1 ARE PENDING) (IA 1/2020 FOR CD OF 374 DAYS IN FILING THE APPEAL IS PENDING) STATEMENT OF OBJECTION TO IA 1/2020 IS RETURNED WITH OFFICE OBJECTION) | (PAR/POS, ) | SANJAY S KATAGERI | G B NAIK & P G NAIK FOR R2 & R3 R1-DECEASED R1(a) & R4-CONSIGNMENT DETAILS NOT FOUND | ||||||
| 5 | RFA 100479/2022 REG: IA 2/2024 FOR DIRECTION (ADMITTED 21/10/2022) (TCR RECEIVED AT TCR BRANCH) (PAPER BOOK + CERTIFIED COPIES OF EXHIBITS K/B) (CH MOVED) | (PAR, ) | SANJAY S KATAGERI (VK+NOC) | HARSHAVARDHAN M PATIL FOR R1-R3 (VK+NOC) R4-KALGUDEEPA-SD R5 IS MINOR R/BY R3 IRANAGOUDA K KABBUR FOR R6-R12 | |||||
| 6 | RFA 100417/2023 REG: IA 1/2024 FOR RECALLING THE ORDER DTD. 05.04.2024 BY CD OF 36 DAYS IN FILING THE APPLICATION | (DEC/INJ, ) | BAHUBALI N. KANABARGI | RAGHAVENDRA A PUROHIT FOR C/R (CP 22269/2023) M K SANNAKKI & V M SANNAKKI FOR C/R CP 23604/2023) | |||||
| 7 | RFA 100461/2023 REG: IA 1/2024 FOR RECALLING THE ORDER DTD. 19.06.2024 | (DEC/PAR, ) | A G HIREMATH S S BETURMATH | M G HOTTI SANTOSH B DODDAMANI FOR C/R CP NO.22450/2023 | |||||
| 8 | RFA 100156/2024 REG: 1) IA 2/2024 FOR CD OF 14 DAYS IN FILING THE ABOVE APPEAL 2) IA 1/2024 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (PAR/POS, ) | DINESH M KULKARNI | ||||||
| 9 | RFA 100167/2024 REG: 1) IA 4/2024 FOR CD OF 560 DAYS IN BRINGING LRS ABATEMENT IN BRINGING LRS & BRINGING LRS OF DECEASED APPELLANT 2)IA 1/2024 FOR CD OF 745 DAYS IN FILING THE ABOVE APPEAL 3) IA 3/2024 FOR PRODUCTION OF ADDL. DOCUMENTS 4) IA 5/2024 FOR DISPENSATION OF CERTIFIED COPY OF ORDERS DTD. 25.05.1988 5) IA 2/2024 FOR STAY | (PAR/POS, ) | CHETANA S. BIRAJ | ||||||
| 10 | RFA 100408/2024 REG: 1) IA 1/2024 FOR CD OF 849 DAYS IN FILING THE ABOVE APPEAL 2) IA 2/2024 FOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTION (CH MOVED) | (PAR/POS, ) | GAYATRI S R T M NADAF | ||||||
| ADMISSION | |||||||||
| 11 | RFA 100241/2023 A/W 1) MEMO FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS (VALUATION REPORT) FILED IN COURT ON 05/06/2024 2) STATEMENT OF OBJECTION TO MEMO FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS FILED BY ADV FOR R3 3) MEMO FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS FILED IN COURT ON 22/08/2023 4) MEMO DTD. 23.07.2024 A/W VALUATION REPORT FILED IN COURT (DATE) | (FDP, ) | MRUTYUNJAY TATA BANGI S S YALIGAR | R1-NALINI - SD SHIVARAJ S BALLOLI FOR R2 (VK + NOC) ANANDKUMAR A MAGADUM & ARCHANA A MAGADUM FOR R3 | |||||
| 12 | RFA 100067/2024 A/W IA 1/2024 FOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTION | (PAR/POS, ) | SATHISH.M.S | ||||||
| 13 | RFA 100399/2024 A/W IA 1/2024 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (SP, ) | S S BAWAKHAN SIDDHARTH SUMAN GOPAL B PATIL SANJAYKUMAR S K | ||||||
| 14 | RFA 100405/2024 A/W IA 1/2024 FOR STAY (DATE) | (DEC/POS, ) | SANTOSH B MALLIGAWAD | ARUN L NEELOPANT & KAVITA S JADHAV FOR C/R1 & C/R2 IN CP 23048/2024 | |||||
| 15 | RFA 100407/2024 A/W 1) IA 1/2024 FOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTION 2) IA 2/2024 FOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTION (CH MOVED) | (PAR/POS, ) | VITTHAL S TELI | ||||||
| FURTHER HEARING | |||||||||
| 16 | CRL.A 100493/2023 (HEARD-IN-PART) A/W IA 2/2024 FOR SUSPENSION OF SENTENCE & GRANT OF BAIL A/W STATEMENT OF OBJECTIONS (ADMITTED ON 18/12/2023) (APPELLANT/ACCUSED IS IN CUSTODY SINCE 22/11/2018) (TCR + PB K/B) (DATE) | (C, ) | GANAPATI M BHAT | ADDL. SPP FOR RESPONDENT | |||||
| FINAL HEARING | |||||||||
| 17 | RFA 100298/2019 (V/O/DTD. 26.09.2024 FOR CONTINUATION OF SUBMISSION BY ADV FOR APPELLANT) (ADMITTED ON 02.09.2024) (FILING OF PAPER BOOK IS DISPENSED WITH V/O/DTD. 02.09.2024) (DATE) | (PAR/POS, ) | J S SHETTY & N H PATIL (VK+NOC) | NARAYAN V YAJI FOR C/R2 (CP NO 20210/2019) (RETURNED WITH OFFICE OBJECTION) A P MURARI FOR R1(a) TO (p), R2 TO R10 R12 TO R17 VISHWANATH HEGDE FOR R21 R22 R23 R32 & R34 V/O/DTD. 22.08.2024 NOTICE TO STEPS TO BRING ON RECORD LRS OF DECEASED R1 STAND DISPENSED WITH V/O/DTD. 02.09.2024 FURTHER ORDERS ON SERVICE OF NOTICE NOT BE NECESSARY IN THE APPEAL | |||||
| 18 | RFA 100667/2022 (ADMITTED ON 27/10/2023) (TCR RECEIVED AT TCR BRANCH) (V/C/O/DTD : 27/02/2024 FILING OF PB IS DISPENSED WITH FOR TIME BEING) (DATE) | (PAR/POS, ) | GURUDEV GACHCHINAMATH PRASHANT PATTAR (VK+NOC) | R H ANGADI FOR R1 & R2 | |||||
| FOR THE DICTATION OF JUDGEMENT | |||||||||
| 19 | RFA 100411/2017 A/W 1) IA 3/2017 FOR PRODUCTION OF ADDL. DOCUMENT 2) MEMO FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS 3) MEMO FOR PRODUCTION OF COPIES OF DEMAND DRAFT & AGREEMENTS FILED BY ADV FOR APPELLANT 4) BRIEF SYNOPSIS / WRITTEN SUBMISSION FILED BY ADV FOR APPELLANTS (ADMITTED ON 15/03/2023) (PB K/B) (TCR RECEIVED AT TCR BRANCH) (DATE) | (SP, ) | F V PATIL and NANDISH PATIL | VITTHAL S TELI FOR R1(a)(i) (ii) (iii) R1(B)-SERVICE HELD SUFFICIENT V/O/DTD. 07.12.2023 S V DESHPANDE FOR R1(b) R1(c): LATA-SD R2: SURESH-SD R5: THE COMMISSIONER OF THE PROVIDENT FUNDS, EPFO, HUBBALLI - SD AGA FOR R3 V/O/DTD. 30.07.2024 TIRUMALESH FOR R4 R1(a)-DECEASED | |||||
| PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDER AT 4.30PM | |||||||||
| 20 | CRL.A 100013/2021 | (374(Cr.PC)/415(BNSS), ) | ASHOK R KALYANASHETTY (VK FILED ON 01/08/2022) | ADDL. SPP ANURADHA DESHPANDE AMICUS CURIAE FOR PW1 | |||||
| Connected With | |||||||||
| CRL.A 100255/2021 (ADMITTED ON 02/12/2021) (APPELLANT/ACCUSED NO.4 IS IN CUSTODY SINCE 21/12/2017) | (C, ) | PRASHANT S KADADEVAR | ADDL. SPP ANURADHA DESHPANDE AMICUS CURIAE FOR PW1 | ||||||
| CRL.A 100339/2020 (ADMITTED ON 18/01/2021) (A1, A3 ARE IN CUSTODY SINCE 21.12.2017) (2 PB`S - VOLUME - I, II & III NOTES, SYNOPSIS & TCR K/B) | (C, ) | JAGADISH PATIL | ADDL. SPP ANURADHA DESHPANDE AMICUS CURIAE FOR PW1 | ||||||
| 21 | CRL.A 100611/2022 | (C, ) | N R KRISHNAPPA (VK) GOURISHANKAR S MOT FOR A1 | ADDL SPP FOR RESPONDENT | |||||
| 22 | CRL.A 100494/2023 | (C, ) | GANAPATI M BHAT | ADDL SPP FOR RESPONDENT | |||||
| 23 | CRL.A 100495/2023 | (C, ) | MASEKAR RATAN GOPAL RAM P GHORPADE | ADDL SPP FOR RESPONDENT | |||||
| 24 | RFA 100308/2024 | (SP, ) | A P MURARI SHIVANI A MURARI | V/O/DTD. 24.07.2024 S B DODDAGOUDAR FOR R1-R5 SHRIKANT T PATIL & ROHIT S PATIL FOR R1 & R2 S B DODDAGOUDAR FOR C/R3 IN CP 21694/2024 FILED ON 29.07.2024 (RETURNED WITH O/O) A C CHAKALABBI & S B DODDAGOUDAR FOR C/R3 IN CP NO.22050/2024 FILED ON 07.06.2024 (RETURNED WITH O/O) | |||||