| IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU ON Friday THE 27th Day Of September 2024 at 10:30:00 AM BEFORE | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| THE HON`BLE DR. JUSTICE CHILLAKUR SUMALATHA | |||||||||
| COURT HALL NO : 25.0 LIST NO : Cause List No. 1 | |||||||||
| Slno | Case No | Adv for Pet/Appl/Comp | Adv for Resp | ||||||
| ORDERS | |||||||||
| 1 | MFA 6468/2021 REG: FURNISHING OF FPF, C/ACK, COPIES ETC., TO ISSUE NOTICE TO R4 FOR 3RD TIME 2) MEMO FILED FOR HAVING DEPOSITED AMOUNT V/O DTD 22/8/24 (DATE) | (MV, D ) | PET: IFFCO TOKIO GIC LTD PRADEEP B | RES: K P ASHRAF AND OTHERS MUZAFFAR AHMED FOR R1 & R2 A M VENKATESH FOR R5 NOORAIN LEGAL RESOLUTION FOR R1 & R2 (NOC NOT OBTAINED) R3- MOHAMMED MUBASHIR SD | |||||
| 2 | MFA 7182/2021 REG: NON FILING OF VK FOR RESPONDENT V/O DTD 28/8/24 2) NON FILING OF ACK FOR HAVING SERVED THE COPY V/O DTD 28/8/24 (DATE) | (MV, I ) | PET: CHIKKAMADAMMA SANATH KUMARA K M | RES: THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER D VIJAYA KUMAR (VK NOT FILED) | |||||
| 3 | MFA 3428/2022 REG: MEMO FOR DISPENSATION OF NOTICE TO R2 (DATE) | (MV, I ) | PET: CHOLAMANDALAM GENERAL GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED LINGARAJ H S | RES: ARUNKUMARA AND OTHERS SHIVAKUMARAPPA T C FOR R1 | |||||
| Connected With | |||||||||
| MFA.CROB 165/2022 REG: MEMO FOR DISPENSATION OF NOTICE TO R1 2) IA 1/22 FOR CD OF 130 DAYS IN FILING | (, ) | PET: ARUNAKUMARA SHIVAKUMARAPPA T C | RES: HANUMANTHAPPA AND OTHERS H S LINGARAJ FOR R2 | ||||||
| 4 | MFA 6213/2022 REG: COUNSEL FOR APPELLANT HAS NOT FILED ACK FOR HAVING PAID COST OF RS.500/- TO THE HIGH COURT ADVOCATES LIBRARY FUND 2) NON FILING OF ACK FOR HAVING SERVED COPIES ON COUNSEL FOR R2 2) IA 1/22 FOR CD OF 149 DAYS IN FILING (NOTE: SIGNATURE OF THE PRESIDING OFFICER NOT FORTHCOMING AT OPERATIVE PORTION OF JUDGMENT) (DATE) | (MV, I ) | PET: SMT. SUCHITHRA RAJARAMA S | RES: MR. NAMRATH RAJ AND OTHERS C SHANKAR REDDY FOR R2 (VK NOT FILED) V/O DTD 6/8/24 NOTICE TO R1 IS D/W | |||||
| 5 | MFA 6589/2022 REG: STEPS TO BE TAKEN IN R/O R1 (SINCE 3 TIMES NOTICE ISSUED) (DATE) | (MV, I ) | PET: SRI. SURESH GIRIMALLAIAH | RES: SRI. BOREGOWDA AND OTHERS P S JAGADISH FOR R2 | |||||
| Connected With | |||||||||
| MFA 6592/2022 REG: STEPS TO BE TAKEN IN R/O R1 (SINCE 3 TIMES NOTICE ISSUED) | (MV, I ) | PET: SRI. SHIVARAJU GIRIMALLAIAH | RES: SRI. BOREGOWDA AND OTHERS P S JAGADISH FOR R2 | ||||||
| 6 | MFA 7640/2022 REG: FURNISHING OF FPF, C/ACK, WITH C/ADDRESS TO ISSUE E-NOTICE TO R4 FOR 3RD TIME (DATE) | (MV, D ) | PET: SHRIRAM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD., ANUP SEETHARAM RAO | RES: SMT MUNIVENKATAMMA AND OTHERS SUSHMITHA G FOR R1 TO R3 LAKSHMINARAYAN C FOR R5 C R RAGHAVENDRA REDDY FOR R6 | |||||
| 7 | MFA 2237/2023 REG: MEMO FOR RETURN OF ORDER SHEET FILED BY ADV FOR RESPONDENT 2) IA 1/23 FOR CD OF 17 DAYS IN FILING (TCR K/B) (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD MANJULA NEMICHANDRA TEJASWI | RES: MR BALAKRISHNA @ BALAKRISHNA POOJARY AND OTHERS GURUPRASAD B R FOR R1 R2- A JANARDHAN GOWDA SD | |||||
| 8 | MFA 7714/2023 REG: FURNISHING OF FPF, C/ACK, COPIES ETC., TO ISSUE NOTICE TO R8 FOR 2ND TIME 2) IA 1/23 FOR STAY (DATE) | (MV, D ) | PET: M/S KOTAK MAHINDRA PRIME LTD., SUMANA NAGANAND | RES: MRS MALATHI AND OTHERS DHANANJAY KUMAR FOR C/R1 TO C/R3 IN (CP 14675/23) (CAVEAT RETURNED WITH O/OBJN) PRAKASHA M FOR R4 R5- MANJUNATH SD R6- S KALAISELVI SD R7- UDAY KUMAR SD | |||||
| 9 | MFA 4151/2024 REG: NOTE IN CAUSE TITLE WITH REGARD TO DECEASED PETITIONER 4 I.E., ANWAR & LR`S DETAILS (DATE) | (MV, D ) | PET: SMT RIHANA SULTHANA AND OTHERS SUBHASH SRINIVASA RANGACHAR | RES: ICICI LOMBARD GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD AND OTHERS | |||||
| 10 | MFA 4247/2024 REG: COUNSEL SUBMISSION WITH REGARD TO DISCREPANCY OF VEHICLE NUMBER IN TRIAL COURT JUDGMENT (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: THE MANAGER A N KRISHNA SWAMY | RES: SHRI DEVAIAH A M AND OTHERS | |||||
| 11 | MFA 4283/2024 REG: COUNSEL SUBMISSION WITH REGARD TO DISCREPANCY OF VEHICLE NUMBER STATED IN TRAIL COURT JUDGMENT (IA 1/24 FOR STAY IS PENDING) (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: THE MANAGER A N KRISHNA SWAMY | RES: SHRI UTTAPPA B S AND OTHERS | |||||
| 12 | MFA 4286/2024 REG: COUNSEL SUBMISSION WITH REGARD TO DISCREPANCY OF VEHICLE NUMBER STATED IN TRIAL COURT JUDGMENT (IA 1/24 FOR STAY IS PENDING) (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: THE MANAGER A N KRISHNA SWAMY | RES: SHRI BANCY BOPPANNA AND OTHERS | |||||
| 13 | MFA 4364/2024 REG: MAINTAINABILITY OF APPEAL AGAINST THE JUDGMENT PASSED IN MVC 4442/2020 SINCE VALUE OF THE APPEAL IS BELOW 1 LAKHS (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: THE MANAGER A N KRISHNA SWAMY | RES: SHRI BINU MANDANNA AND OTHERS | |||||
| 14 | MFA 4588/2024 REG: COUNSEL SUBMISSION WITH REGARD TO DISCREPANCY OF VEHICLE NO. STATED IN THE TRIAL COURT JUDGMENT (IA 1/24 FOR STAY IS PENDING) (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: THE MANAGER A N KRISHNA SWAMY | RES: SHRI KENIL CARIYAPPA AND OTHERS | |||||
| 15 | MFA 4657/2024 REG: COUNSEL SUBMISSION WITH REGARD TO OFFICE OBJECTION I.E., NAME OF INSURANCE CO. IS STATED AS BAJAJ ALLIANCE GIC LTD., WHEREAS IN CAUSE TITLE OF APPEAL MEMO & SEAL AFFIXED ON VK AS BAJAJ ALLIANZ GIC LTD., COUNSEL TO CLARIFY (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: THE MANAGER, A N KRISHNA SWAMY | RES: MR DEEPAK M H AND OTHERS | |||||
| 16 | MFA 5810/2024 REG: NON COMPLIANCE OF OFFICE OBJECTIONS 2) IA 1/24 FOR DISPENSATION WITH THE DEPOSITING AWARD AMOUNT | (ECA , ) | PET: SRI P G RAMESH KUMAR H V PRAVEEN GOWDA | RES: MUBBEN TAJ AND OTHERS | |||||
| 17 | MFA 6260/2024 REG: NON COMPLIANCE OF OFFICE OBJECTIONS (CH MOVED) | (MV, D ) | PET: THE MANAGER D VIJAYAKUMAR | RES: SMT. VARALAKSHMI AND OTHERS | |||||
| HEARING - INTERLOCUTORY APPLN | |||||||||
| 18 | MFA 5902/2021 REG: IA 1/24 FOR WITHDRAWAL OF DEPOSITED AMOUNT BEFORE THIS COURT 2) NON FILING OF APPLICATION FOR SUBSTITUTED SERVICE FOR ISSUANCE OF NOTICE TO R1 & R6 (TCR K/B) (DATE) | (MV, D ) | PET: IFFCO TOKIO GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD B C SHIVANNE GOWDA | RES: SMT. NETHRAVATHI AND OTHERS G V NARASIMHAMURTHY FOR R3 TO R5 (R2 MINOR REP BY R1) | |||||
| 19 | MFA 6914/2021 (FOR FURTHER ORDERS) REG: IA 1/21 FOR CD OF 59 DAYS IN FILING 2) NON FILING OF MEMO FOR APPEARANCE FOR R1 & R2 V/O DTD 17/9/24 (DATE) | (MV, D ) | PET: SRI R BASAVARAJ AND OTHERS VENKATA REDDY C M | RES: MEDICAL OFFICER (H AND FWS) AND OTHERS GA HCGP FOR R1 & R2 (MA NOT FILED) | |||||
| 20 | MFA 5452/2023 REG: IA 1/23 FOR CD OF 208 DAYS IN FILING | (MV, D ) | PET: KUMARASWAMY H R AND OTHERS CHANDRASHEKARA K A | RES: D. BORAEGOWDA AND OTHERS | |||||
| 21 | MFA 2238/2024 REG: IA 1/24 FOR CD OF 31 DAYS IN FILING (CH MOVED) | (MV, D ) | PET: THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER SEETHA RAMA RAO B C AND ANUP SEETHARAM RAO | RES: SMT MANGALI SUGAMMA AND OTHERS PRUTHVI WODEYAR FOR R1 TO R4 | |||||
| 22 | MFA 5815/2024 REG: IA 1/24 FOR CD OF 191 DAYS IN FILING (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: SRI MUDDAPPA SUSHMITHA G | RES: SRI MANJUNATHA G AND OTHERS | |||||
| 23 | MFA 5903/2024 REG: IA 1/24 FOR CD OF 280 DAYS IN FILING (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: SMT. NARAYANAMMA GOPAL KRISHNA N | RES: SRI CHANDRAPPA M AND OTHERS | |||||
| FRESH MATTER/S | |||||||||
| 24 | MFA 3467/2024 A/W IA 1/24 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (MV, D ) | PET: THE MANAGER SHANKARA REDDY C | RES: SRI ANNAIAH AND OTHERS | |||||
| 25 | MFA 3997/2024 A/W ACCEPTANCE OF VK FILED BY B PRADEEP FOR R1 SINCE NOTICE NOT YET ORDERED (DATE) | (MV, D ) | PET: CHANDRI BAI AND OTHERS GIRISH B BALADARE | RES: THE MANAGER AND OTHERS B PRADEEP FOR R1 | |||||
| 26 | MFA 4280/2024 A/W IA 1/24 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: THE MANAGER A N KRISHNA SWAMY | RES: SHRI JINU B AND OTHERS | |||||
| 27 | MFA 4397/2024 A/W IA 2/24 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: MAGMA HDI GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED A N KRISHNA SWAMY | RES: SRI N SRINIVASA AND OTHERS | |||||
| 28 | MFA 4408/2024 A/W IA 1/24 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (MV, D ) | PET: MAGMA HDI GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD A N KRISHNA SWAMY | RES: SMT M DIVYA AND OTHERS | |||||
| 29 | MFA 4419/2024 A/W IA 2/24 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: MAGAMA HDI GENRAL INSURANCE CO LTD A N KRISHNA SWAMY | RES: SHRI MAHADEV AND OTHERS | |||||
| 30 | MFA 4511/2024 A/W IA 2/24 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: MAGMA HDI GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED A N KRISHNA SWAMY | RES: SHRI MUNIRAJA AND OTHERS | |||||
| 31 | MFA 6049/2024 (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: SRI. SHANKARAPPA SUSHMITHA G | RES: SRI. RAMESH B V AND OTHERS | |||||
| 32 | MFA 6078/2024 A/W IA 1/24 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (MV, D ) | PET: THE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD SHANKARA REDDY C | RES: SRI E ASHOK AND OTHERS | |||||
| 33 | MFA 6148/2024 A/W IA 1/24 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: M/S THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO LTD G S MARULAIAH | RES: ITIHAS H R AND OTHERS | |||||
| 34 | MFA 6257/2024 A/W IA 1/24 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (MV, I ) | PET: RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED ASHOK N PATIL | RES: SRI. KRISHNAPPA P AND OTHERS | |||||
| 35 | MFA 6258/2024 A/W IA 1/24 FOR STAY (CH MOVED) | (MV, D ) | PET: THE BRANCH MANAGER ASHOK N PATIL | RES: MALLESHAPPA AND OTHERS | |||||
| PART HEARD IN HEARING MATTERS | |||||||||
| 36 | MFA 6475/2022 (ADMITTED ON 21/8/24) (DATE) | (MV, I ) | PET: NATIONAL INSURANCE CO LTD MANJULA NEMICHANDRA TEJASWI | RES: VIJAYA S AND OTHERS P NATARAJU FOR R1 R2- THOUFEEQ M R SD R3- MOHAMMED M M SD | |||||
| DISMISSAL | |||||||||
| 37 | MFA 3696/2022 (TCR K/B) (DATE) | (MV, I ) | PET: MUNIYAPPA GOPAL KRISHNA N | RES: THE MANAGING DIERCTOR D VIJAYAKUMAR D VIJAYA KUMAR | |||||
| ADMISSION | |||||||||
| 38 | MFA 611/2021 (TCR KEPT BELOW) (DATE) | (MV, D ) | PET: THE MANAGER, SHRIRAM GENERAL INS CO LTD A N KRISHNA SWAMY | RES: SMT. UMADEVI AND OTHERS RAJU S FOR R1 TO R3 R4 - VISHWAKUMAR GOWDA G R5 - RAMAIAH R ARE SD | |||||
| 39 | MFA 5462/2021 (TCR K/B) (DATE) | (MV, D ) | PET: SMT KALAVATHAMMA AND OTHERS SUGUNAMMA AND SUGUNA R REDDY | RES: SRI V MARUTHI CHOWDRY AND OTHERS B A RAMAKRISHNA FOR R2 R1- SD V MARUTHI COWDRY SD | |||||
| 40 | MFA 7308/2022 A/W FURNISHING OF PF, C/ACK COPIES, ETC., TO ISSUE NOTICE TO R1 FOR 1ST TIME (DATE) | (MV, I ) | PET: SMT SRIDEVI SUGUNAMMA AND SUGUNA R REDDY | RES: M/S S I F C LOGISTICS PRIVATE LIMITED AND OTHERS K NAGARAJAIAH FOR R2 (NOTICE NOT YET ORDERED IN R/O R1) | |||||
| Connected With | |||||||||
| MFA 7306/2022 | (MV, D ) | PET: SMT N LAKSHMI AND OTHERS SUGUNAMMA AND SUGUNA R REDDY | RES: M/S S I F C LOGISTICS PRIVATE LIMITED AND OTHERS K NAGARAJAIAH FOR R2 V/O DTD 20/6/24 NOTICE TO R1 IS D/W | ||||||
| MFA 7305/2022 REG: IA 1/22 FOR CD OF 135 DAYS IN FILING | (MV, D ) | PET: M A SATHYANARAYANA SHETTY AND OTHERS SUGUNAMMA AND SUGUNA R REDDY | RES: M/S S I F C LOGISTICS PRIVATE LIMITED AND OTHERS K NAGARAJAIAH FOR R2 V/O DTD 9/3/23 NOTICE TO R1 IS D/W | ||||||
| MFA 7307/2022 REG: MEMO FOR DISPENSATION OF NOTICE TO R1 2) IA 1/22 FOR CD OF 135 DAYS IN FILING | (MV, D ) | PET: SRI ANIRUDH AND OTHERS SUGUNAMMA AND SUGUNA R REDDY | RES: M/S S I F C LOGISTICS PRIVATE LIMITED AND OTHERS K NAGARAJAIAH FOR R2 | ||||||
| MFA 7315/2022 (HON`BLE COURT GIVEN DATE ON 25/10/24) | (MV, D ) | PET: SRI ASWATHANARAYANA SHETTY AND OTHERS SUGUNAMMA AND SUGUNA R REDDY | RES: M/S S I F C LOGISTICS PRIVATE LIMITED AND OTHERS K NAGARAJAIAH FOR R2 V/O DTD 22/8/24 NOTICE TO R1 IS D/W | ||||||
| MFA 7332/2022 REG: MEMO FOR DISPENSATION OF NOTICE TO R1 2) IA 1/22 FOR CD OF 135 DAYS IN FILING | (MV, I ) | PET: SRI DODDA NARASIMHAPPA SUGUNAMMA AND SUGUNA R REDDY | RES: M/S S I F C LOGISTICS PRIVATE LIMITED AND OTHERS K NAGARAJAIAH FOR R2 | ||||||
| 41 | MFA 3411/2023 A/W NON FILING OF ACK FOR HAVING SERVED COPY TO R1 V/O DTD 13/9/24 (DATE) | (MV, D ) | PET: MADAR SAB AND OTHERS CHANDRASHEKARA REDDY M V | RES: RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD AND OTHERS D VIJAYA KUMAR FOR R1 (VK NOT FILED) V/O DTD 16/8/23 NOTICE TO R2 TO R4 IS D/W | |||||
| 42 | MFA 5776/2023 (DATE) | (MV, I ) | PET: GOWTHAM. M CHANDRASHEKAR SWAMY K B | RES: SOWJANYA. R AND OTHERS H S LINGARAJA FOR R2 V/O DTD 24/8/23 NOTICE TO R1 IS D/W | |||||
| FINAL HEARING | |||||||||
| 43 | MFA 4971/2021 A/W AWAITING TCR (ADMITTED ON 17/9/24) (DATE) | (MV, I ) | PET: SRI SADANANDA THYAGARAJA S | RES: SRI PRADEEP S AND OTHERS SHIVARAJ PATIL FOR R3 R1- PRADEEP S SD R2- SHEKAR SD | |||||
| 44 | MFA 835/2022 A/W MEMO A/W CITATIONS FILED BY ADV FOR APPELLANT (ADMITTED ON 4/2/22) (DATE) | (MV, I ) | PET: SRI. MANJUNATH U.R LATUR SURESH MAHALINGAPPA | RES: THE MANAGING DIRECTOR K.S.R.T.C G LAKSHMEESH RAO | |||||
| 45 | MFA 1014/2022 (ADMITTED ON 18/3/24) (DATE) | (MV, D ) | PET: LAKSHMAMMA AND OTHERS SREENIVASAN M Y | RES: MOHD RISHAD AND OTHERS S V HEGDE MULKHAND FOR R2 V/O DTD 15/2/2022, NOTICE TO R1 D/W | |||||
| 46 | MFA 1083/2022 A/W MEMO A/W COPY OF ORDER DTD 13/4/22 FILED BY ADV FOR R2 (ADMITTED ON 14/2/22) (DATE) | (MV, I ) | PET: MR K M NAGESH NAGARAJA R C | RES: MR BASAVARAJU AND OTHERS G LAKSHMEESHA RAO FOR R2 R1- BASAVARAJU SD | |||||
| 47 | MFA 1326/2022 (ADMITTED ON 12/9/24) (DATE) | (MV, DM ) | PET: K.M.SARDHAR @ K.M.SARDHAR PASHA GIRISH B BALADARE | RES: THE MANAGER, THE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD AND OTHERS SANMATHI E I FOR R1 V/O DTD 12/9/24 NOTICE TO R2 & R3 IS D/W | |||||
| 48 | MFA 1876/2022 (ADMITTED ON 19/9/24) (DATE) | (MV, D ) | PET: MANASA H AND OTHERS CHETHAN B | RES: THIMMEGOWDA AND OTHERS B A RAMAKRISHNA FOR R2 V/O DTD 19/9/24 NOTICE TO R1 IS D/W | |||||
| 49 | MFA 6572/2022 A/W IA 1/24 TO REFER THE APPELLANT TO MEDICAL BOARD (ADMITTED ON 22/9/22) (DATE) | (MV, I ) | PET: CHETHAN H P KAVITHA H C | RES: B.K.JAYARAM AND OTHERS RAJENDRA HEGDE FOR R2 V/O DTD 26/7/24 NOTICE TO R1 D/W | |||||
| 50 | MFA 3447/2024 (ADMITTED ON 21/8/24) (DATE) | (MV, I ) | PET: M/S ICICI LOMBARD GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD B C SHIVANNE GOWDA | RES: SAGAR S.H. AND OTHERS RANGEGOWDA N R FOR R1 R2- HANUMANTHARAJU SD | |||||